Confessions

I catfished my own boyfriend to test him and now I do not know what to do

Before you judge me, hear me out. Then judge me. I probably deserve it.

My boyfriend and I have been together for 2 years. We live separately — he is in Fort Worth, I am in Arlington. For the past few months, something has felt off. He is on his phone more, working late more often, and our intimacy dropped significantly.

I know what you are thinking. Just talk to him. I did. He said work was stressful and he was tired. I believed him the first time. The second time. By the third time I started doubting.

So I did something I am not proud of.

I created a fake Instagram profile. Used photos of an attractive woman (AI-generated, not a real person). Built out the profile to look realistic. Then I followed him, liked a few of his photos, and waited.

He followed back within an hour.

Within a day, HE slid into the DMs. Not me. He initiated.

Within a week, the fake profile and my boyfriend were having full conversations. Flirty. Personal. He told "her" he was single. He told "her" he lived alone. He asked "her" to meet up for drinks in Fort Worth.

I have screenshots of everything.

Here is where it gets complicated: technically, he has not cheated. He flirted with a profile that does not exist. He agreed to a date that will never happen. But the INTENT is there. He told a stranger he was single. He pursued someone who was not me.

I have not told him yet. I do not know how to bring it up without admitting what I did. "I catfished you" is not a great opening line.

My friends are split. Half say he failed the test and I should leave. Half say I am psycho for setting the trap and I violated his trust.

Both sides might be right.

The real question is: if I had not done this, would I have ever found out? Or would I have stayed in a relationship with someone who was one real DM away from cheating?

I know this is messy. I know I am not the hero of this story. But I needed to tell someone.

Community ReportAutomatedSource: Community ReportPublished: Apr 5, 2026, 12:03 AM

Both of you are wrong but he is MORE wrong. You set a trap, which is unhealthy and shows trust was already gone. But he walked into it eagerly, lied about being single, and tried to meet up. That is not a gray area. He was actively trying to cheat.

I did this exact thing in 2024 and I regret it. Not because my ex was innocent (he was not) but because it consumed me. The obsession with testing him became its own toxic behavior. Leave him based on the gut feeling you ALREADY had. You did not need the proof.

This is simultaneously the most unhinged and the most relatable thing I have read on this app. I think a lot of people have thought about doing this. You actually did it. I am not sure if that is brave or concerning.

Him responding to a random IG model within an hour and DMing her first is the real tell. That is a man who was already looking. The fake profile just made it easier for him.

You need to just end it. Do not show him the screenshots. Do not explain the catfish. Just say it is not working and leave. Showing the evidence opens you up to him flipping the narrative and making YOU the villain.

Hot take: the relationship was already over before you made the fake profile. The catfishing did not break trust — it revealed that trust was already broken. You just confirmed what you already knew.